29 Vintage Collectible Toys Worth Digging Out of the Attic

Do you remember the days of playing with your favorite childhood toys? Whether it was a teddy bear, a Barbie doll, or action figures, chances are that these vintage collectible toys still evoke fond memories. After all, who could forget the thrill of unwrapping presents on Christmas morning or spending hours in the sandbox building castles and forts? 

For many, these nostalgic memories have led to an interest in collecting vintage toys from their youth and as such, the right toy could bring you in some decent bucks. We went digging and found some of the most sought-after vintage collectible toys worth digging out of your attic and who knows, you might run across one of these at a garage sale, antique shop, or flea market.

From a classic gaming system to beloved dolls and action figures, take a look at what these are worth.

5 Collectible Toys from the 50s

When it comes to valuable vintage toys, some of the most sought-after are those made in the 1950s.

1. Kettler Bobby Car: This iconic pedal car was first released in Germany back in 1949, making it one of the oldest play vehicles still around today! Made out of metal, plastic, and rubber components, these cars can be worth up to $500 depending on their condition. 

2. Marx Fort Apache Play Set (1954): Produced by Louis Marx & Co., this popular play set depicted an Old West fort complete with soldiers’ barracks, horses, wagons, and other accessories that made playing “Cowboys Vs Indians” so much fun! It has become a highly sought-after toy amongst collectors with some selling for upwards of $900 or more! 

3. Hasbro Mr. Potato Head (1952): This classic toy was the first of its kind, allowing children to mix and match various accessories with a plastic potato body that they could manipulate in any way they liked! Complete sets can be worth up to $2,000 and even individual pieces can fetch a nice price depending on their condition.

4. Marx Big Wheel (1957): This three-wheeled pedal vehicle was an instant hit with kids when it first came out in ’57 and is still a popular toy today! Some original models can be worth up to $350 or more depending on their condition and rarity. 

5. Remco Baby Thinker (1958): This educational toy was designed to help babies and toddlers develop their motor skills by manipulating a variety of levers, dials, and buttons. It can be worth up to $500 if it’s in good condition!

5 Collectible Toys from the 60s

The 1960s began an explosion of popular toys that still hold nostalgic value today. 

1. G.I Joe Action Figure: This iconic action figure made its debut in 1964 and has become a staple in any toy collector’s collection. Depending on the model and condition, these figures can sell for anywhere from $200-$5,000! 

2. Easy Bake Oven (1963): This classic toy is an iconic part of many households’ childhood memories. Though they are not as valuable as some other vintage collectibles, complete sets can still fetch up to $200! 

3. Hot Wheels (1968): Mattel’s classic line of miniature cars have been around since 1968 and have become a favorite of many collectors. Rare or limited-edition pieces can be worth up to several thousand dollars! 

4. Super Jigsaw Puzzle (1967): Produced by Ideal Novelty & Toy Co., these popular jigsaw puzzles featured a variety of different scenes and images, ranging from military-inspired designs to popular cartoon characters. In near-mint condition, these can sell for up to $250! 

5. Rock ‘Em Sock’Em Robots (1966): This classic two-player game features a variety of robots that face off in an arena. Collectors can expect to pay up to $300 for the original version, which is still sought after today!

The 5 Best Collectible Toys from the 1970s

The 1970s were a time for experimentation and innovation when it came to toys, with many classic lines of action figures being introduced during this era. 

1. Star Wars Action Figures (1977): The original line of Star Wars action figures released in 1977 is still incredibly popular amongst collectors today, with some individual figures selling for up to five thousand dollars!

2. Stretch Armstrong (1976): This iconic action figure was first released in 1976 and quickly became a staple of many households’ toy collections. Though versions are still available, collectors can get up to $500 for original figures in good condition. 

3. Cabbage Patch Kids (1978): These popular dolls were first released in 1978 and have since become one of the most iconic toys of all time. Original dolls can be worth up to $500, depending on their condition!

4. Evil Knieval Toys (1977): This line of action figures was released in 1977 to coincide with the daredevil’s stunts. Original figures can fetch up to $500, depending on their condition and rarity.

5. Atari Consoles and Games (1977): Atari released its first console in 1977, forever changing the world of video gaming. Rare and collectible games can be worth up to several hundred dollars, while consoles from this era can fetch up to $1000 or more! 

6 Toys from the 80s Worth Money Today

The 1980s saw a resurgence in the demand for great toys and some of them are worth a decent chunk of change.

1. Masters of the Universe: This iconic line of action figures was first released in 1982 and has since become one of the most sought-after lines amongst toy collectors. Rare figures can fetch up to $500 or more depending on their condition.

2. Transformers (1984): This classic line of robots in disguise revolutionized the toy industry with its innovative approach to action figures. Original figures can be worth up to $500 depending on their condition and rarity. 

3. My Little Pony: These iconic ponies first became popular in 1983 and have become a staple amongst collectors ever since. Rare or limited-edition figures can be worth up to $1,000 or more! 

4. Teddy Ruxpin: This popular teddy bear was first released in 1985 and quickly became a staple amongst both young and old audiences alike. Original bears can go for upwards of $200 depending on their condition.

5. Rainbow Brite: Released in 1984, this popular doll quickly became one of the most iconic toy lines of its time and original dolls can be worth up to $500 or more!

6. Nintendo Gaming Systems: Nintendo revolutionized the gaming industry with its release of the NES in 1985. Collectors can fetch hundreds or even thousands of dollars for rare consoles or games from this era!

8 Valuable Collectibles from the 90s

The 90s saw the release of some of the most iconic toy lines in history, and many of these items have become highly sought-after by collectors. 

1. Beanie Babies (1995): These popular plush toys were first released in 1995 and quickly became a hit with both young and old audiences alike. Original pieces can be worth up to several hundred dollars or more depending on their condition and rarity.

2. Tamagotchi (1996): First released in 1996, these digital pets became one of the most popular toys of its time and are still highly sought-after by collectors today. Rare versions can be worth up to $1000 or more! 

3. Furby (1998): This electronic pet was released by Hasbro in 1998 and has since become a staple amongst toy collections. Original Furbies can be worth up to $500 depending on their condition and rarity. 

4. Sega Dreamcast (1998): Released in 1998, the Sega Dreamcast quickly became one of the most popular gaming consoles of its time. Rare versions can be worth up to several hundred dollars or more! 

5. Pokémon Cards (1996): The classic trading cards first released in 1996 have become one of the most sought-after collectibles around the world. Original cards can fetch prices upwards of $1000 or more depending on their condition and rarity.

6. Magic The Gathering Cards (1993): This classic card game has been one of the most popular collectible card games ever since it first released. Rare cards can be worth up to several hundred dollars or more but the most expensive Magic The Gathering card is the Black Lotus. This extremely rare card was released in the Alpha Edition in 1993 and can fetch up to $50,000. Even more depending on its condition and the market demand. It’s considered to be the most iconic card in Magic The Gathering due to its high power level and huge potential for combos. 

7. Star Wars Episode 1 Toys: The highly anticipated prequel to the original trilogy was released in 1999 and merchandise for this movie has become some of the most sought-after collectibles around. Original toys from this collection can be worth up to several hundred dollars or more! 

8. Power Rangers Action Figures: This iconic line of action figures was first released in 1993 and has since become a staple amongst toy collections. Rare or limited-edition pieces can be worth up to several hundred dollars or more depending on their condition and rarity. 

There are hundreds, if not thousands, of collectible toys from the past few decades that are still worth money today. If you’re looking to sell or buy vintage or collectible toys, it’s important to research their value and rarity before making a purchase. With the right knowledge and patience, you can find the right buyer or some truly unique and valuable pieces that will make great additions to your collection!